Claim to Fame season 2 cast: winner, show clues, theories on the identities of their celebrity relatives and status in the competition (2025)

Claim to Fame season 2 cast: winner, show clues, theories on the identities of their celebrity relatives and status in the competition (1)

Jump to:

  • Claim to Fame season 2 winner

Back in time for summer TV is Claim to Fame season 2. In the series' first run last year, fans eagerly flocked to the show to play detectives, doing their best to unmask the secret family connection each of the contestants had with a well-known celebrity.

While some familial connections were easier to spot than others and social media experts were able to scroll through a few posts to find out who was who, the overall mystery surrounding the premise of the show hugely captivated viewers.

Now in season 2, ABC has made the big guessing game even more difficult with a brand-new crop of contestants. We've done our best to list the major clues dropped as to the identity of each celebrity relative, and developed a few theories in the process.

With that said, let’s take a look at the Claim to Fame season 2 cast.

Carly

Claim to Fame season 2 cast: winner, show clues, theories on the identities of their celebrity relatives and status in the competition (2)

Major clues: Uncle has been a big Hollywood star since the ‘80s and has an Oscar.

Status in competition: eliminated week 1

Our guess: We’re going to venture to assume that Carly might be related to Bruce Springsteen, although not his niece. Springsteen in fact has received an Oscar.

Get the What to Watch Newsletter

The latest updates, reviews and unmissable series to watch and more!

Celebrity relative: It looks like Carly’s uncle is two-time Oscar winner Tom Hanks. He is perhaps one of Hollywood’s most beloved actors and he’s starred in Forrest Gump, Philadelphia and more recently in A Man Called Otto and Asteroid City.

Travis

Claim to Fame season 2 cast: winner, show clues, theories on the identities of their celebrity relatives and status in the competition (3)

Major clues: Travis said his father is his famous relation. Also, Travis asserted his dad is an actor and a Critics Choice Award winner. Travis worried that reciting the first 100 digits of pi would put him in a “nerd category,” which apparently could happen anyway based on who his father is.

Status in competition: eliminated week 2

Our guess/celebrity relative: Again putting our detective skills to the test, we were able to determine that Travis is the son of American astrophysicist, author, science communicator and actor, Neil deGrasse Tyson.

Jane

Claim to Fame season 2 cast: winner, show clues, theories on the identities of their celebrity relatives and status in the competition (4)

Major clues: Jane claimed her famous relative is her father, a musician and a Grammy winner. However, only two of these details are true.During week 2, she revealed that her relative was born in 1946.

Status in competition: eliminated week 3

Our guess: We aren’t sure what to guess as it pertains to Jane, so we’ll throw out the name Ozzy Osbourne. However, we think she could be the Grammy winner’s niece.

Celebrity relative: Jane, or Jada Star as it turns out, is the niece of Grammy-winning Country legend and actress, Dolly Parton.

Shayne

Claim to Fame season 2 cast: winner, show clues, theories on the identities of their celebrity relatives and status in the competition (5)

Major Clues: Shayne shared that her celebrity family member is her father, he is a musician and he’s a Grammy winner when she first arrived. However, as she continued on in the competition, from images of a crown and references to Buckwheat, it started to appear she had a connection to a famous SNL comedian.

Status in competition: eliminated week 4

Our guess: Shayne’s identity is harder to pinpoint. If we had to say, we’re going to guess she’s related to singer Rick James. Although, as the show goes on in the competition, we're starting to think she may be related to Eddie Murphy.

Celebrity relative: As it turns out, Shayne is indeed related to Hollywood legend Eddie Murphy. She’s his daughter. Eddie Murphy hardly needs an introduction having starred in classic movies like Nutty Professor, Doctor Dolittle, Coming to America, Trading Places and most recently, You People.

Cole

Claim to Fame season 2 cast: winner, show clues, theories on the identities of their celebrity relatives and status in the competition (6)

Major clues: Cole asserted that his father is the famous one in his family. Additionally, Cole said his dad is a singer and Grammy recipient. One of these details is a lie.

Status in competition: eliminated week 5

Our guess/celebrity relative: Call us supersleuths, because we did a little digging and were able to determine that Cole is in fact the brother of Grammy-winning artist Alicia Keys.

Olivia

Claim to Fame season 2 cast: winner, show clues, theories on the identities of their celebrity relatives and status in the competition (7)

Major clues: Olivia stated that her famous relative is a TV personality and he is the recipient of a Razzie award.During week 3, the clues revealed as it pertains to her famous celebrity were a headband with yellow aliens, a red cross and "Happy New Year" glasses.

Status in competition: eliminated week 6

Our guess: We’re going to take a stab in the dark and say she’s related to host of The Bachelor, Jesse Palmer. Either that or perhaps the legend Dick Clark.

Celebrity relative: Although there weren’t a ton of clues that gave viewers an inkling, as it turns out, Olivia is the niece of Masked Singer judge Jenny McCarthy.

Hugo

Claim to Fame season 2 cast: winner, show clues, theories on the identities of their celebrity relatives and status in the competition (8)

Major clues: Hugo shared that his grandfather was once "the most powerful man in the world" and is a Nobel Prize winner.A picture of a donkey was revealed as a clue for Hugo, which could represent the US Democratic Party.In week 7 it was revealed that his celebrity relative is 98 years old, and was born in 1924 in Plains, GA.

Status in the competition: eliminated week 7

Our guess: We’re going to lean into the Nobel Prize winner angle and put out the theory that Hugo is the grandchild of either Al Gore or Jimmy Carter, both of whom have received a Nobel Peace Prize.

Celebrity relative: As it turns out, Hugo is the grandson of President Jimmy Carter.

JR

Claim to Fame season 2 cast: winner, show clues, theories on the identities of their celebrity relatives and status in the competition (9)

Major clues: JR has a famous brother who is a musician.During week 2, he revealed his relative was born in Lithia Springs, Georgia.In week 3, his clues were a blue pacifier and a white chef's hat.During week 6, clues revealed for his celebrity relative included an old man, a town and a road. Additionally, in week 7 the celebrity's known famous associates were listed as assumedly Jack Harlow and Billy Ray Cyrus.

Status in competition: eliminated week 8

Our guess: While we originally guessed r&b sensation Khalid, we now think the clues lean more toward JR's famous relative being Lil Nas X.

Celebrity relative: As it turns out, JR is in fact the older brother of Lil Nas X.

Karsyn

Claim to Fame season 2 cast: winner, show clues, theories on the identities of their celebrity relatives and status in the competition (10)

Major clues: Karsyn stated that her famous relative is her uncle, who happens to be a musician and he was inducted into the Hall of Fame. One of these details isn’t true.During week 3, Karsyn-related clues included a trophy, an eraser with the minus sign and the letter "E," a steering wheel, two records, the number 4 and a mug.In week 4, Karsyn identified her famous relative with a steering wheel and tire.During the challenges of week 7, it was revealed that her relative is 48, was born in 1974 and is from Kannapolis, NC. Additionally, the celebrities known associates are presumably Mark Zuckerburg, Jay-Z and Danica Patrick.

Status in competition: eliminated week 9, episode 9

Our guess: We’re actually going to assume that Karsyn’s uncle is not a musician but rather someone in sports. We initially guessed, former Denver Broncos quarterback John Elway, but it's looking as if her relative is someone in NASCAR.

Celebrity relative: Karsyn is the niece of famed NASCAR driver, Dale Earnhardt Jr.

Chris

Claim to Fame season 2 cast: winner, show clues, theories on the identities of their celebrity relatives and status in the competition (11)

Major clues: Uncle is a musician who Chris looks and sounds like. Plus, his uncle has a Hollywood Walk of Fame Star. His relative was big in the 1970s.In week 2, his clue package included a puppy and a heart.In week 7, it's revealed that Chris' relative is 65 and from Ogden, UT. Additionally, the celebrity has known associates Andy Williams, Andrew Lloyd and Weird Al Yankovic. In week 8, it’s revealed that Chris’s famous relative won Dancing with the Stars season 9.

Status in competition: eliminated week 9, episode 10

Our guess/celebrity relative: Based on looks, we initially believed he was related to John Mayer. However, after doing some research, it turns out Chris is the son of music legend, Donny Osmond.

Monay

Claim to Fame season 2 cast: winner, show clues, theories on the identities of their celebrity relatives and status in the competition (12)

Major clues: Monay stated her dad is famous, he’s an athlete and he’s an Emmy winner. Again though, one of these details is not true.In week 3, two major clues of a fedora and a cloud with a lightning bolt were revealed.In week 7 it's revealed that her famous relative is 57 and from Plymouth, NC. In week 8 it’s revealed that Monay’s famous relative worked on Saturday Night Live and was in Spider-Man: Far From Home.

Status in the competition: eliminated week 10, episode 10

Our guess/celebrity relative: At first glance, we believed Monay was related to NBA champion Bruce Bowen. However, during week 5 of the show, Gabriel interpreted a clue that Monay's famous relation was someone with ties to Saturday Night Live and Curb Your Enthusiasm. After doing some research with that clue in mind, it turns out that her name is Jerrica Brooks and she's the daughter of actor/comedian JB Smoove. He wrote for SNL and stars in Curb Your Enthusiasm.

Claim to Fame season 2 winner

Gabriel

Claim to Fame season 2 cast: winner, show clues, theories on the identities of their celebrity relatives and status in the competition (13)

Major clues: Gabriel claimed his brother is an NAACP Award winner. His famous relative was born in San Diego.In week 3, a red and yellow star, a propeller hat and drumsticks were revealed as clues for Gabriel. During week 4 Gabriel mentioned that his brother was on Nickelodeon with Keenan and Kel.In week 7, the major clue of a celebrity with at least 10 kids was shared.

Status in competition: winner

Our guess: We’re going to guess Gabriel is related to House of Payne and Our Kind of People star Lance Gross, who has won an NAACP Image Award. Although, with the Nickelodeon clue, perhaps he's related to someone like Nick Cannon.

Celebrity relative: Gabriel is indeed the little brother of Nick Cannon.

Watch Claim to Fame season 2 on ABC every Tuesday, or stream it the next day on Hulu.

Claim to Fame season 2 cast: winner, show clues, theories on the identities of their celebrity relatives and status in the competition (14)

Terrell Smith

Terrell Smith has a diverse writing background having penned material for a wide array of clients including the federal government and Bravo television personalities. When he’s not writing as Terrell, he’s writing under his pseudonym Tavion Scott, creating scripts for his audio drama podcasts. Terrell is a huge fan of great storytelling when it comes to television and film. Some of his favorite shows includeThe Crown,WandaVision, Abbot ElementaryandGodfather of Harlem.And a fun fact is he's completely dialed into the TLC90 Day Fiancéuniverse.

More about tv shows

Surviving the Handsome Devil tells the story of the woman who unknowingly dated serial killer Bruce LindahlThe Bear season 1 marathon airing on FX starting tonight, June 2

Latest

Britain's Got Talent fans praise 'sensational' Syndie Christmas despite controversy over the singer's previous experience
See more latest►

Most Popular
The Bold and the Beautiful recap for May 30, 2024: 'this time it's war'
Which Love Island USA season 5 couples are still together?
My top movies to stream in June: 14 movies on Netflix, Max, Peacock and more
Stephen Merchant reveals on set secrets from The Outlaws season 3 and what it's like working with Baby Reindeer's Jessica Gunning
Eric cast: who's who in the Netflix thriller
I was a MoviePass devotee, here's why the MoviePass, MovieCrash doc got me riled up
Eric episode 6 recap: does Vincent bring Edgar home?
Eric episode 5 recap: a breakthrough in both cases
Eric episode 4 recap: Vincent is given an ultimatum
Eric episode 3 recap: Ledroit interrogates Vincent
Eric episode 2 recap: Vincent's secrets start to stack up
Claim to Fame season 2 cast: winner, show clues, theories on the identities of their celebrity relatives and status in the competition (2025)

FAQs

Who is everyone related to in Claim to Fame season 2? ›

Who has been revealed on 'Claim to Fame' Season 2?
  • Carly — Tom Hanks' niece.
  • Travis — Neil deGrasse Tyson's son.
  • Jane (real name Jada Star) — Dolly Parton's niece.
  • Shayne — Eddie Murphy's daughter.
  • Cole — Alicia Keys' brother.
  • Olivia — Jenna McCarthy's niece.
  • Hugo — Jimmy Carter's grandson.
  • JR — Lil Nas X's brother.
Aug 28, 2023

What are Karsyn's clues on Claim to Fame? ›

On week three, we finally get our first bit of information on Karsyn. Unfortunately, it comes in the form of a clue that Shayne pulled but couldn't really decipher. The clue is this series of images: trophy, pencil with eraser, minus sign, E, face with a question mark on it, record player, record player, 4, beer.

What are Monday's clues on Claim to Fame? ›

Monay. Biggest clues: Says her father is an athlete with an Emmy, but one of these is a lie. Photo clues include a fedora, pink padlock on a chain necklace, and a cloud with a lightning bolt.

What were Chris's final words? ›

Chris McCandless' last words were captured in a final photograph that he took of himself before his death. In the photo he held a sign that read, "I have had a happy life and thank the Lord. Goodbye and may God bless all!"

Is Chris related to Donny Osmond? ›

He also reveals that he knows very well that everyone's mom knew he was Donny's son right away, but that he's happy to help a new generation realize just how big of a legend his father is. Read on for our full interview and see who everyone on Claim to Fame season 2 was related to here.

Who is related to Lark on Claim to Fame? ›

Her clue also suggests that her aunt is a famous runway model. In another challenge, she was connected to George Clooney, whom she later revealed has a tequila company with her uncle. Celebrity relative: Lark confirms her famous relative is her aunt, Cindy Crawford, when she is sent home.

Who is Pepper related to on Claim to Fame? ›

Pepper was revealed to be the granddaughter of Dean Martin in season 1, episode 10.

Is Monay related to Steve Harvey? ›

Monay's fellow competitors on Claim to Fame believed she was Steve Harvey's daughter, but she's actually comedian and actor J.B. Smoove's daughter. Monay strategically deceived others by claiming her celebrity relative was an athlete who won an Emmy, but it turns out her father is J.B. Smoove.

Is Karsyn related to Dale Earnhardt? ›

Racing is family. Dale Earnhardt Jr.'s niece Karsyn Elledge is competing in the #BC39 in memory of Bryan Clauson. See how it all played out Friday at 6PM ET on NBCSN.

Who is Monay related to on Claim to Fame? ›

Her clue card also teased that her celebrity relative was on Curb Your Enthusiasm. Celebrity relative: Monay, whose real name is Jerrica Brooks, was revealed to be the daughter of Curb Your Enthusiasm actor JB Smoove. Status on the show: Eliminated in the season 2 finale.

Who is Gabriel's relative on Claim to Fame? ›

Many outlets are reporting that Gabriel's celebrity relative is likely Nick Cannon. The TV personality was born in San Diego, was on the Nickelodeon show “All That” and starred in the film “Drumline.” He's also been in headlines over the past few years for having children with multiple women.

What is JR's Clue Claim to Fame? ›

Hugo's Claim to Fame celebrity relative revealed

In Episode 6, Gabriel received JR's wine cellar clue, which mentioned "Old Town Road" and solidified to him (and later Chris) that JR was Lil Nas X's relative. However, in Episode 8, JR eliminated himself by becoming the third person to incorrectly guess Chris' relative.

What was Hud's clue on Claim to Fame? ›

What were the main clues about Hud's identity in Claim to Fame? The main clues about Hud's identity included a rebus puzzle with the phrase "Come on baby, make it hurt so good" referencing John Mellencamp's hit song, and hints about his father being a famous 90s singer with a mustache.

What are the clues for Dominique's Claim to Fame? ›

Dominique shared that her celebrity relative is her father, although that could also not be true. He is not known for being an actor. She also revealed that the word "Eulogy" was a clue for her relative. Another clue revealed was a pinstripe suit jacket, and she said her dad was always known to be a sharp dresser.

How did they determine it was Chris? ›

Chris' Social Security number allowed them to identify the hiker as Chris McCandless from Virginia.

What was Hugo's clue on Claim to Fame? ›

Hugo's Wine Room clue was revealed during Claim to Fame episode 4. When Chris won the challenge as team captain, he pulled Hugo's clue. The clue had a finger indicating the word "come," the "&" symbol, a deer, the symbol for "in," and a police chief.

Who is Carson's celebrity relative on Claim to Fame? ›

While the other contestants never saw the clue for Karsyn handed out in the trivia/musical chairs challenge, viewers got a chance to see it said "Danica Patrick hosts a podcast, which featured Karsyn's relative who spoke about his career and his late father." This would have solidified Karsyn's relative to be Dale ...

Is Chris on Claim to Fame related to the Osmonds? ›

And by people, we mean the Claim to Fame Season 2 cast, who sooner thought Elton John was from Utah before they remembered the Osmonds exist. In case you haven't put the clues together yet, Chris is Donny Osmond's son. This shouldn't be a spoiler, as Season 2 Episode 8 revealed a clue that confirms this theory.

References

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Recommended Articles
Article information

Author: Sen. Emmett Berge

Last Updated:

Views: 6204

Rating: 5 / 5 (80 voted)

Reviews: 95% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Sen. Emmett Berge

Birthday: 1993-06-17

Address: 787 Elvis Divide, Port Brice, OH 24507-6802

Phone: +9779049645255

Job: Senior Healthcare Specialist

Hobby: Cycling, Model building, Kitesurfing, Origami, Lapidary, Dance, Basketball

Introduction: My name is Sen. Emmett Berge, I am a funny, vast, charming, courageous, enthusiastic, jolly, famous person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.